Why the Word “Why” May Be Sabotaging Your Conversations (and Confidence)

“Why” is a word we learn early. Why did you do that? Why didn’t you finish your homework? Why aren’t you listening? Used well, it can spark discovery — but more often than not, it puts us on the defensive.

That instinct starts young. The first time you were asked “why” by a parent, teacher, or coach, it probably wasn’t out of curiosity — it was a signal that you were in trouble. Over time, our brains learn to hear “why” not as an invitation to explain, but as an accusation to fend off.

And here’s the kicker: it doesn’t just happen in conversation — it also happens inside our own heads. The inner critic’s favorite sentence starters often sound like: “Why did you say that?” or “Why can’t you get it together?” Instead of helping us grow, those questions keep us stuck in self-judgement and shame.

So what’s the alternative? In this edition of Reading Between the Lines, Rob Volpe explores how removing the word “why” — externally and internally — can lead to more honest dialogue, calmer self-reflection, and stronger empathy. You’ll learn how to rephrase your questions to open doors instead of shutting people down, and how a simple habit called Whyless Wednesday can help you break the “why” cycle for good.

👉 Read the full newsletter or watch the You Tube video to go deeper.