The Man Who Lost His Tomorrow: What Mental Time Travel Teaches Us About Hope and Empathy
You time traveled today, probably before you finished your coffee. Replaying a conversation from yesterday. Rehearsing one that hasn't happened yet. Scientists call this mental time travel, and as far as we know, humans are the only species that does it this way.
The concept comes from psychologist Endel Tulving, who argued that memory isn't a filing cabinet, it's a vehicle. The same system that lets you re-experience your past, episodic memory, is what lets you pre-experience your future. This capacity has a shadow side: worry, the spiral where one bad moment with your kid becomes an imagined future twenty years out. But it also has a bright side, and that side is often mislabeled.
Hope is not optimism. That distinction, from Rebecca Solnit's Hope in the Dark, is the hinge of this piece. Optimism is passive: things will work out. Hope is active: the future is unwritten, so you go looking for the opening. Think of every trapped-hero movie scene, the trash compactor in Star Wars, Bond tied to a chair with the clock running. The hero's instinct, keep looking, there's a way out, is hope doing the future-oriented mind's best work.
The proof comes from a man who lost the ability entirely. In 1981, a motorcycle accident destroyed both hippocampi of a thirty-year-old man neuroscientists came to know as K.C. He kept his general knowledge and his procedural memory, he could still explain how to change a tire, but he lost every personal episode of his own life. When researchers asked what he'd be doing tomorrow, he couldn't answer. He described the feeling as blank, the same word he used for his past. The discovery: remembering who you were and imagining who you'll be run on the same system. When it breaks, it breaks in both directions at once.
The turn: pointing it at someone else. Everything above is self-directed, your past, your future, your way out. But the same machinery can run outward. Point it at another person, fueled by empathy instead of self-interest, and you get the ability to imagine a way through their problem. That's the fifth step of the 5 Steps to Empathy framework, Use Solution Imagination, described a new way: it's mental time travel on someone else's behalf.
Key takeaways
Mental time travel, the ability to mentally relive the past and pre-live the future, is a documented human capacity tied to the hippocampus and episodic memory.
Hope and optimism are not the same thing. Optimism waits for a good outcome; hope actively searches for one.
The case of K.C., studied by Tulving after a 1981 accident, showed that remembering the past and imagining the future rely on the same neural system.
Empathy is mental time travel pointed at someone else, using the same imaginative capacity to picture a way forward for another person instead of yourself.
Common questions
What is mental time travel? A term coined by psychologist Endel Tulving for the human ability to mentally revisit the past and imagine the future using the same memory system, called episodic memory.
What's the difference between hope and optimism? Optimism is a passive belief that things will work out. Hope is an active search for a way to make things work out, because the future is understood as unwritten and shapeable.
Who was K.C.? Kent Cochrane, a Toronto man who lost both hippocampi in a 1981 motorcycle accident. He retained factual and procedural memory but lost the ability to recall personal past events or imagine his personal future.
How does this relate to empathy? The 5 Steps to Empathy framework's fifth step, Use Solution Imagination, works by applying the same future-imagining capacity to another person's situation instead of your own.
This post extends the fourth episode of What Does It Mean to Be Human? with Maria Ross.
Read the full newsletter.
Watch the Companion Video